So now, "here's the rest of the story."
Actually, I guess it's pretty obvious: I'm approaching the point where I need to make some decisions on what ballast to use and, being a "prototype modeler" I'd like it to be as close to the prototype as possible. While the list of considerations is short - availability, size, and color - it gets a little complicated, as you'll see.
One of the most important considerations for a layout this size is that the ballast product continues to be available for a while. I'd rather buy as I go, willing to accept minor color variations (what the Missus - a knitter - calls "dye lot") and don't want to have to buy a 50 gallon drum of the stuff all at once. Unfortunately, one of my early choices - Highball Products - is no longer in business (anybody have an alternative?). So I plan to check out additional options at the Big Springfield Show this weekend.
This should be relatively straightforward, but . . .
The photo above is Woodland Scenics "Medium" ballast, supposedly for HO scale.
And above is WS "Fine" ballast. Offhand, it looks a little too small to me - but that may be because most of the HO model railroads I've seen use the larger "HO" ballast. Comparing this size to prototype photos, though, tends to show that smaller is better.
Speaking of prototype photos, let's segue to the toughest consideration - and not just for someone who's a bit colorblind. Here's what I mean . . .
Above shots are at Wethersfield, showing the Valley Line. But only the north end of the Valley Line. The Hartford-Middletown portion of the line was reballasted with white gravel (not traprock) during the summer of 1945. But the remainder of the line south of Middletown to Old Saybrook was a mix of sand and cinders . . .
So at least 2-3 different colors (and 2 sizes) for the Valley Line. What about the Air Line?
According to John Wallace (the source of most of these photos, including the ones above), the Air Line had traprock ballast due to heavier traffic on the line (including documented use of the New Haven's big 3500s - likely wending their way back from Readville Shops, not in revenue service). This ballast appears to be a dark grey.
And what of the Shore Line? One of the commenters on the previous post were asking about my use of brown ballast - not what you'd expect on a New England railroad, right?
Ok - I admit my colorblindness, and it could be that that's actually a dark grey - and an almost-70-year-old photo is bound to have some color shift, but that looks brown(ish) to me. And is consistent with the color of traprock mined in Branford and Wallingford, CT - major sources of ballast for the New Haven.
But consider this . . .
Also on the Shore Line, and a much-more-typical gray traprock ballast we're all familiar with.
But modeling the New Haven is often, um, complicated . . .
I don't know about you, but I count THREE colors here - gray traprock, on top of brown traprock, on top of cinders (heh - presumably on top of dirt/sand....)
So that's a little sampling of the prototype photos I'm looking to for guidance in choosing which size and color ballast to use on my layout (which, remember, depicts the Valley Line north AND south of Middletown, the Airline, and the Shore Line).
However, just as important as the photos are all of YOU that can lend a little guidance on color/size and advice for what products to use. So please weigh in!
Hi Chris, I will bring you a sample of what I am using to Springfield to see if you like it.ReplyDelete
I am going to Springfield to also look for ballast. I hope find some Highball stuff lying around. I think the Scenic Express ballast is too "shiny" myself.ReplyDelete
Hey Seth Erazmus here of the Friends of the Valley RR fame. I’ve spent a lot of years on the unrestored, “New Haven authentic” line between Goodspeed and Middletown. Much of the line is the typical sand/cinders. There are a few sections where the NH used round river rock as ballast. It was quite unsuccessful, as it acts like ball bearings under the ties. Most of the rail is 78lbs and a few patches of 80lbs and 74. Keep that code 55 handy for that true branchline look! If there is one thing to keep in mind when building a NH branchline, think “patchwork”. Sand, cinders, river stone, and even some trap rock should all be part of the mix.ReplyDelete